Ethics and Laws of Medical Practice
Overview
Medical practice is governed by both ethical principles and legal frameworks that ensure patient safety, professional conduct, and public trust in healthcare systems.
Core Ethical Principles
Autonomy
- Definition: Respect for patient self-determination and decision-making
- Application: Informed consent, respecting patient choices
- Limitations: Must be balanced with beneficence and non-maleficence
Beneficence
- Definition: Acting in the best interest of the patient
- Application: Providing beneficial treatments, promoting wellbeing
- Clinical practice: Evidence-based medicine, patient-centered care
Non-maleficence
- Definition: “Do no harm” - avoiding causing harm to patients
- Application: Risk-benefit analysis, avoiding unnecessary interventions
- Considerations: Treatment side effects, medical errors
Justice
- Definition: Fair distribution of healthcare resources and benefits
- Application: Equal access to care, fair triage systems
- System level: Resource allocation, healthcare policy
Legal Framework
Medical Professional Conduct
- Licensure requirements
- Professional standards of care
- Scope of practice limitations
- Continuing professional development
Patient Rights
- Right to informed consent
- Right to confidentiality and privacy
- Right to access medical records
- Right to refuse treatment
Legal Responsibilities
- Duty of care to patients
- Documentation standards
- Mandatory reporting obligations
- Professional liability
Ethical Dilemmas in Clinical Practice
End-of-Life Decisions
- Advance directives and living wills
- Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders
- Palliative care vs. aggressive treatment
- Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (jurisdiction dependent)
Confidentiality vs. Public Safety
- Reporting infectious diseases
- Disclosing risks to third parties
- Tarasoff principle (duty to warn)
- Professional boundaries
Resource Allocation
- Triage in emergency situations
- Organ transplantation prioritization
- Cost-effective care decisions
- Healthcare disparities
Professional-Patient Relationship
Trust and Communication
- Building therapeutic alliance
- Effective communication strategies
- Cultural competence
- Language barriers
Boundary Issues
- Dual relationships
- Accepting gifts
- Social media boundaries
- Personal relationships with patients
Medical Error Management
Ethical Approach
- Full disclosure of errors
- Apology and remediation
- System improvement focus
- Support for affected parties
Legal Aspects
- Medical malpractice concepts
- Standard of care definitions
- Defensive medicine considerations
- Quality improvement initiatives
Professional Integrity
Conflicts of Interest
- Financial relationships with industry
- Research funding disclosures
- Referral patterns
- Gift acceptance policies
Professional Development
- Maintaining competence
- Recognizing limitations
- Seeking consultation
- Lifelong learning commitments